Tuesday, December 17, 2013

What’s in a name?

Photo taken from Folio Weekly


By Will Brown

The first time I saw the name Nathan Bedford Forrest I was a freshman in college who was distracted from another project.

At the time, I was studying in a library in the center of a campus that was once a plantation. The plantation owner was Florida’s first territorial governor, William Duval. If you’ve heard that surname it’s probably because there is a county in Northeast Florida named after him.

But, let’s stick with Forrest. Who was this guy whose name has become national news 136 years after his death?

He was the founder of the Ku Klux Klan. It was social organization for whites that was founded in Tennessee during Reconstruction. After about two decades the organization became dormant. A similar whites-only organization with the same name was created in the early years of the 20th century with the hoodies, acts of American terrorism and mob mentality that most of us associate with the Ku Klux Klan.

Nathan Bedford Forrest
It was announced Monday night a high school that was named after Forrest in Jacksonville will be renamed in July 2014. The decision to switch the school’s name to either West Side High or Firestone High has caused tension and divisiveness at a school where 62 percent of the 1,327 students are black, 23 percent are white and 9 percent are Hispanic.

Was Forrest a great man? He had his faults like all of us. Considering the decision to name a school after him in an area of the country history has shown he did not visit nor influence was made by a school board that wanted to send a one-finger salute to a government that demanded it integrate the back in the 50s, it should not have been too incendiary to change the name in 2013.

If you look at the history of the naming of Nathan B. Forrest High School, the students originally wanted the school to be named Valhalla,” said Nikolai Vitti, superintendent of Duval County Public Schools during Monday’s meeting.  “Politics reigned and as a response to desegregation and the civil rights movement, the school was named Nathan B. Forrest. That was not the will of the students, and considering the opinion of the students in this process, I think it is an opportunity to give voice to students whose voices were not heard in the beginning and can certainly be heard now."

Then again the school is located in a town that is named after a general who was notorious for murdering and displacing American Indians. It’s a part of a school district that has schools named after educators, astronauts, politicians and pre-Colonial explorer who tried to steal land from the Spanish.

Like a lot of locales, Florida history is complex and simple at the same time. One of the easiest ways to understand it is to figure out the who and what things are named after and why.

There are local governments named after Confederates in Brevard, Pasco, Lee and Levy counties. There is a county in South Florida named after the former governor who dredged the Everglades — Broward. There are counties that are named after animals, fruit, conquistadors and, of course, Native Americans.

There are more than 400 municipalities and thousands of roads and buildings named after people, places and things, some of which, like Forrest High, may no longer be politically correct.

Long before I read about the origins of most Florida communities in Allen Morris’ 1995 book “Florida Place Names: Alachua to Zolfo Springs” Nathan Bedford Forrest’s story captivated me because it was one that I was not taught in high school.

It was probably too divisive and politically incorrect to speak about a man with considerable warts. Then again, I went to high school in a place where a NAACP leader was bombed on Christmas day, a piece of history that I learned from my father and aunt who are old enough to tell me the complete story of America’s first civil rights martyr.

America is a country that wants warm and tingly feelings with our information. We want our opinions to be validated by our peers. We want to believe that what we are told is completely accurate, even if there is much more context beneath the surface.

Nathan Bedford Forrest is yet another whose name has hit the iceberg of political correctness and sunk. As satisfying as the renaming of Forrest High may be, it’s yet another reminder that it’s easier to whitewash uncomfortable history rather than to learn it, understand it and refuse to repeat it.

Laughs and liveliness,
-Wb